The Zimbabwean Coup: Is There Hope for Democracy?

A very young supporter waves a Zimbabwean flag at Mugabe's election rally in Harare 26 February 2002 in Harare. AFP PHOTO / AFP PHOTO / ALEXANDER JOEALEXANDER JOE/AFP/Getty Images

The year 2017 was shaping up to be the first year without a coup since 2007. Then came Zimbabwe. Early in the morning of November 15, the army’s chief of staff appeared on television and said, “This is not a military takeover.” But with armored personnel carriers rolling through the streets and the President under house arrest, it seemed unlikely to be anything but.

Why would the military deny that a coup is taking place? Because coups are considered illegitimate and a violation of an international norms. When a change in government is labeled a coup, the international community is more likely to pressure the new government to take steps toward democracy. Egypt is instructive in this case. The overthrow of the democratically elected Muslim Brotherhood in 2013 was considered a coup by scholars, but was not labeled as such uniformly. The US government did not call it a coup and did not (at least publicly) pressure the new al-Sisi government to move toward democracy.

Coups are relatively rare now, but back in the 1960s and 70s there were years when over a dozen coups occurred, mostly in Sub Saharan Africa. They were usually violent, often destabilizing, and sometimes they even led to civil war as in the Nigerian coup of 1966. It is no wonder that the United Nations and other organizations have tried to create an anti-coup norm, which would delegitimize them and allow regional actors to try to prevent them.

Are coups always bad?

But are coups always bad? There have been a spate of recent articles promoting some coups as a viable path to democracy. According to political scientists Nikolay Marinov and Hein Goemans,

“…the majority of coups after [1991] … have been followed by competitive elections. … In the post-Cold War era, countries that were most dependent on Western aid were the first to embrace competitive elections after their coups. … While the coup d’e´tat has been (and still is) the single most important factor leading to the downfall of democratic governments, these findings indicate that the new generation of coups has been far less harmful for democracy than their historical predecessors.”

Why is this the case? According to coup scholars Mwita Chacha and Jonathan Powell

“Central to post-coup democratization is the belief that the international community can exert sufficient leverage to coerce coup-born governments to allow a transition to civilian rule.”

And this effect is more pronounced in states more connected to the global economy. Chacha and Powell write,

“A cross-national assessment of over 200 coups from 1950 to 2010 provides strong support for the argument, as trade dependence and contract intensive money are far stronger determinants of post-coup democratization than other factors commonly associated with democratization.” 

So will the Zimbabwean coup usher in a democratic transition? It’s too soon to say. The man thought to take the lead, former Vice President, Emmerson Mnangagwa, is a hero of Zimbabwe’s war of independence (along with Mugabe). In fact, until recently he was Mugabe’s right hand and known as “the Crocodile” for his harsh treatment of the opposition. According to Zimbabwean legal scholar Alex T. Magaisa,

“The liberation generation has triumphed by the law of the gun, demonstrating once again the enduring nature of the liberation war narrative in Zimbabwean politics. It served Mugabe once, and now it is serving his subordinates. It suggests that the liberation generation will monopolize power for a long time to come, at least for as long as they live, and will not hesitate to use the gun to defend that monopoly on power.”

But there is hope. Following on Chacha and Powell’s research, the leaders of this coup have talked about renewing Zimbabwe’s economic strength. They will most likely seek renewed trade and direct foreign investment. This will require partners. The new partners, the United States among them, can offer a hand along with pressure for democratic reforms. Elections had been scheduled for next year. We will watch and see.

  • Preliminary-Analysis-missile-test-thumb-ONN

    Preliminary Analysis of 30 September 2021 Anti-Aircraft Missile Test of the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea

    On 1 October 2021, the Korean Central News Agency (KCNA) of the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea (DPRK) reported that the Academy of Defence Science tested a newly developed anti-aircraft missile (see Attachment). The test, which took place on 30 September, also marked the fourth missile test of the DPRK within the same month. Read More
  • observations-on-hypersonic-missile

    Observations on the 28 September 2021 Hypersonic Missile Test of the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea

    The Hwasong-8 test launch marks the first test of a ballistic missile of the IRBM class since 2017. It also demonstrates that the DPRK military industry is trying to fulfil the tasks set out during the Eighth Congress of the Korean Workers’ Party in January 2021. Read More
  • Impact Investors in Shuraako’s Groundbreaking Nordic Fund Visiting Somaliland

    Visionary impact investors in the historic partnership that One Earth Future’s Shuraako program has pioneered through its Nordic Horn of Africa Opportunities Fund will meet next week with clients and partners in Somaliland. Read More
  • Blurring the Lines of Separation; Localizing Ourselves for Peace

    The recent presence of military coups covered in the news may lead people to believe that coups are more prevalent in 2021 than they have been in recent years, however, this perception may warrant further questions pertaining to what qualifies an event as a coup, and how loosely should the term be used? Read more: Read More
  • Secure Fisheries Speaking at the World Cold Chain Symposium 2021

    Secure Fisheries Director, Sarah Glaser, and Field Manager, Mustafe Mohamoud, to participate as featured speakers at the World Cold Chain Symposium (Register Now)

    Secure Fisheries, a program of One Earth Future, is excited to announce its participation in the upcoming virtual World Cold Chain Symposium on September 14th, 9-11 A.M. (EST), hosted by The Global Food Cold Chain Council and the United Nations Environment Programme. Experts from around the world will come together to collaborate on how the cold chain can increase food security, reduce food loss and waste, reduce greenhouse gas emissions and contribute to a more sustainable future. Read More
  • Military Coups in 2021

    The recent presence of military coups covered in the news may lead people to believe that coups are more prevalent in 2021 than they have been in recent years, however, this perception may warrant further questions pertaining to what qualifies an event as a coup, and how loosely should the term be used? Read more: Read More